He described the sheng as the "glue" of his ensemble. He didn't mean an instrument kept to accompaniment, and he resisted a neat split between melody and harmony. He talked instead about swelling chords and sustained pitches that seem to unfold at a different pace from the activity around them, shaping the atmosphere of a passage without carrying its tune. He is less interested in familiar triads than in clusters and larger sonorities that are harder to name. That puts a particular responsibility on me. A sustained note may look simple, but its weight, its length and how it sits against the parts beside it decide whether a texture feels held together or overbalanced.
Julia Luo
I want more people to hear Chinese instruments in new music, and I want the sheng to stay recognisable when they do.
The day before the Wanqu premiere, I faced almost the opposite problem. On 26 August I played Greensleeves with the UK Chinese Orchestra in the festival's Sound of Nature concert at SOAS. Here the melody was familiar before rehearsal began; the question was how to keep it clear in an arrangement played mainly on Chinese instruments. Near the climax, the sheng rises into its bright upper register, and I hear something of a bagpipe in it. That unexpected connection helped me. I didn't need to disguise the sheng or make it sound like a Western instrument.
I did need to judge how much of that brightness the ensemble needed. A high sheng line draws the ear quickly, and more sound wasn't always the answer. I wanted the colour to be heard without turning everyone else into my accompaniment. A dynamic marking helps, but it can't make that decision for me. I had to listen to the whole phrase and ask: is the sheng helping the tune speak, or am I becoming too interested in the colour of my own sound?
The two pieces asked different things of the same instrument. In Greensleeves, I knew the tune and adjusted my balance around it. In Wanqu, I first had to understand music whose phrasing I couldn't predict. My brass training made me fluent at reading ensemble scores and following a conductor; Chinese repertoire gave me another set of expectations about phrasing and articulation. Neither came with an automatic answer.
On the same day I met Ellison, I attended a seminar at the University of Bristol with the Taiwanese sheng musician Li-Chin Li. In the British concert world I know, it is unusual to hear the instrument discussed in such depth. Later, I asked Ellison how he works with performers. He described the value of trying ideas one-to-one, especially when a player can demonstrate a better solution than the one first written down.
That is what I would like to see more of. I can't say whether composers across Britain are getting better at writing for Chinese instruments. I can say what I'd welcome: composers hearing an instrument's existing repertoire before writing for it, and more chances to work with the same musicians over time. Hearing how a sheng player joins notes or places an ornament raises questions a range chart never will. One commission can begin an acquaintance with the sheng; coming back to it lets a composer try something else, and gives me time to grow into their writing. I want more people to hear Chinese instruments in new music, and I want the sheng to stay recognisable when they do.
None of this argues against notation. It shows what notation can't settle by itself. The number of reeds, the way a gesture is physically made, the balance of a chord and the length of another player's phrase all change what the written music becomes in the room. My questions to Ellison were technical and direct because they came from having played his piece.
A note on a page can look perfectly clear until someone tries to play it. In London, I learnt where my part belonged inside Ellison's writing. In Bristol, I asked how the piece had grown and what he might try next. Between those two moments is the work of a musician: hearing what a score asks of an instrument, and finding a way to make it sound.